Retire in Portugal vs Spain: which one is the best? For years, the answer was obvious. Portugal had huge tax exemptions for foreigners. It was the safest country, one of the highest English proficiency levels in Europe. Retirement advisors, expat forums, expat channels all pointed the same direction. Portugal was so much better.
So you might expect that to still be true in 2026. And you would be wrong. Not completely wrong — Portugal still is a great country for foreigners wanting to enjoy their life. I have helped hundreds of expats to decide between those two places in Europe, and I saw how the gap has closed — in certain aspects that hit your wallet hardest, Spain now comes out on top.
Portugal’s famous tax loopholes for retirees have been heavily restricted, while Spain has quietly launched aggressive new programs to attract you. So today we will check both countries through a six-factor comparison built around exactly what matters to someone in your situation — not expat bloggers in their 30s.
The Criteria
We score six things: real estate prices, healthcare quality, safety, language barriers, cost of living, and the most important of all — the amount the government takes from your pocket for things that you never asked for in the first place. Yes, taxes.
For real estate, we compare buying a 70-square-meter apartment in two similar mid-sized cities. For healthcare, we use the JCI-accredited private hospitals as data. For safety, we use multiple crime indicators. For language, the EF English Proficiency Index 2025, the largest objective English ranking in the world. To compare the cost of living, we use Numbeo’s cost of living database. And for tax, we consider a retiree earning around $50,000 per year. One winner per factor.
Comparison 1: Real Estate Prices
For this comparison, we chose two mid-sized cities: Braga in Portugal and Cádiz in Spain. Braga is a major university and tech hub in northern Portugal — with a growing expat community, it punches well above its size. Cádiz is one of the oldest cities in Europe, an Atlantic port in Andalusia with beaches and long promenades.
These two cities are ideal for this comparison since they are similar: both are quite attractive for expat retirees, and are a good proxy of the real estate market in the entire country. Also, they are mid-sized — and if you want to retire abroad, you would not choose a huge, chaotic, expensive, noisy metropolis. Mid-sized cities are better for this case. I personally have been to both, and they are really, really nice places.
Now the part that will shock you: ten years ago, a comparable apartment in Braga, Portugal cost around half what you’d pay for the same thing in Cádiz, Spain. That affordability gap was one of the reasons expats chose Portugal in the first place. But that gap is essentially gone.
Here’s what happened to Portugal’s prices. The market has more than doubled in nominal terms over the past decade, with real appreciation of 90 to 140 percent depending on the region. Portugal recorded the second-largest annual rise in house prices in all of Europe at the end of 2025 — up 17.7%, far above the eurozone average of 5.1%.
The European Commission now estimates Portuguese housing prices at 30 to 35 percent above the EU average. This massive price spike was mostly fueled by tax incentives and foreign investors, combined with a serious lack of new construction. People getting priced out of Lisbon and Porto are moving north, so Braga just isn’t the cheap hidden gem it used to be.
For our 70-square-meter scenario, you’re looking at €140,000 to €161,000 in Braga before transaction costs — transfer tax and other costs add an extra 6 to 8%. Meanwhile, in Cádiz, you can expect a standard two-bedroom apartment to cost between €140,000 and €168,000. Transfer costs add to that an extra of around 7%.
Local Spanish property data shows that Cádiz is actually still cheaper than the national average, and hasn’t even hit its 2008 price peak yet. The headline purchase prices are nearly identical today. But the trajectory is not.
Spain enters this comparison from a less overheated base, with structural room to appreciate. Portugal’s housing market was pumped up by tax breaks that simply don’t exist anymore.
Factor 2 — Healthcare Quality
While in the real estate section we used two mid-sized cities, here we will use two larger cities, for a simple reason: if you have some serious health condition that requires you to travel to the closest metropolis, how well equipped is this metropolis? So here the two contenders are Lisbon and Málaga — both cities have similar population, both cities are regional healthcare centers.
For expat retirees, the most reliable international quality benchmark is the JCI certification — the most famous international healthcare accreditation. Over 1,000 standards, covering patient safety, clinical care, governance, and management. It’s the best way to ensure you’ll get the same standard of care as the best hospitals in Europe and North America.
Lisbon has two hospitals with JCI Certification. The flagship is Hospital da Luz Lisboa — with 500 beds, multilingual staff and a formal international patient program. Alongside it, Hospital Lusíadas Lisboa is also JCI-certified. In the Málaga area, Vithas Xanit International Hospital in Benalmádena has 190 beds, JCI and ISO 9001-accredited, and built specifically to serve foreigners in the region.
So the final score is two JCI-accredited hospitals in Lisbon versus one in Málaga — which is also smaller. If having top-tier medical care nearby helps you sleep at night, Lisbon simply gives you more choices.
Factor 3 — Safety
First of all, let’s put safety into perspective here. The US homicide rate is about 6.4 per 100,000. Portugal has a rate of 0.6. Spain’s is at 0.68. Both countries are at one-tenth of American homicide levels.
But looking just at homicide rates does not transmit a complete idea of safety — other crimes can be very common. Robbery rates for example — the number that most defines the daily experience of actually living somewhere — comes in at 106 per 100,000 for Portugal and 143 for Spain.
Portugal’s safest regions are also, conveniently, among the most appealing for expat retirees (with the exception of the Algarve). Cascais and Oeiras — the coastal corridor west of Lisbon — consistently top the safety lists for long-term residents. The Alentejo interior, anchored by Évora, reports some of the lowest violent crime figures in the entire country. The south is a bit of a question mark. Crime dropped in some parts, but cities like Albufeira still have high numbers.
Where do you need to be more careful in Portugal? Lisbon concentrates the highest absolute numbers of crime. Amadora, just northwest of the capital, carries the highest Crime Index in Portugal at 53, driven by drug-related activity in specific blocks.
Spain’s picture is more uneven. Barcelona leads the national rankings with about 8,563 offences per 100,000 residents in the first half of 2025 — one of the worst in Western Europe by that metric. The north is the safest place: the Basque Country, Asturias, and Navarre have the lowest regional crime rates in Spain. Asturias is remarkable: Gijón, with over 250,000 residents, went a year without recording a single homicide.
One thing about Spanish crime data: they consider theft under €400 as a misdemeanor, not a criminal offense. Those incidents don’t count as serious charges. This artificially decreases Spain’s official theft statistics — the real figure is likely higher than the numbers suggest.
In terms of safety, Portugal comes out ahead — but by a small margin. The next factor is often ignored, but extremely important.
Factor 4 — Language Accessibility
This might be the most underrated factor on the entire list. You’d expect two neighboring Southern European countries to land close together on English accessibility — and you would be wrong.
The EF English Proficiency Index 2025, drawing from test data from 2.2 million people across 123 countries, puts Portugal at 612 — ranked 6th globally, ahead of Germany, Belgium, and virtually every non-Scandinavian country in the world. Spain comes in at 36th with a score around 540. That is a huge gap.
In 2025, Portugal crossed into the “High Proficiency” band for the first time — a real generational shift. Why such a big difference between neighbors? It comes down to one cultural habit.
Portugal usually airs foreign TV shows and movies with subtitles. Spain dubs almost everything into Spanish. Over a lifetime, watching original English media makes a massive difference in how well the locals speak the language.
You can easily get by with English in Spanish expat hubs, but that’s mostly because of the tourist bubble. Try dealing with the local Spanish government or utility companies and you’ll hit a wall without speaking the language. In Portugal, you can usually handle your doctors, bankers, and local bureaucracy entirely in English. And having that ease of communication takes away a huge amount of stress as you get older.
Portugal is the winner here. But here’s the thing — language barrier is not the only barrier.
Relocating to Portugal or Spain?
So many expats spend months researching where to move, make the decision, and then lose another year stuck in visa paperwork, residency applications, and bureaucracy. StartAbroad fixes exactly that. They are specialists in both Spain and Portugal. They handle the process for you — visa applications, residency paperwork, finding your home — specifically for people moving to Portugal and Spain. Retirees, families, remote workers — they’ve done this hundreds of times. Click here to visit StartAbroad and use the code THEEXPAT for a 5% discount on their services.
Factor 5 — Cost of Living (Excluding Rent)
According to Numbeo’s March 2026 data, the cost of living in Spain is 5.9 percent higher than in Portugal overall, excluding rent. Restaurant prices in Spain run 19.8 percent higher. Groceries are 8.4 percent more expensive.
What does that actually look like on the ground? A meal at an inexpensive restaurant runs €12 in Portugal versus €15 in Spain — that’s 25 percent more. A mid-range dinner for two: €45 versus €50. A domestic beer at a bar: €2.50 versus €3.00. Even your morning cappuccino costs €1.79 in Portugal versus €2.07 in Spain.
None of these individually breaks the bank, but if you eat out 20 times a month — which many retirees do — you’re already spending €60 more in Spain just on restaurant meals.
The grocery aisle tells the same story. Chicken comes in at €3.01 per pound in Portugal versus €3.33 in Spain. Local cheese: €4.67 versus €5.64 — a 20 percent gap. Apples, bread, produce — Portugal runs consistently 8 to 10 percent cheaper across most staples. The one exception? Wine is essentially the same in both countries, at around €5 a bottle.
Utilities favor Portugal too — about €116 per month for an 85-square-meter apartment versus €133 in Spain.
Now, Spain does win on a few specific items. Broadband internet runs €29 a month there versus €37 in Portugal — about 21 percent cheaper on connectivity — and their mobile plans are around 11 percent cheaper too. Public transport and gasoline are also cheaper in Spain.
So Spain wins on getting around and staying connected. Portugal wins on everything you put in your mouth — and that’s where most of your daily spending actually goes.
Put it all together, and Numbeo’s overall monthly estimate lands at around €700 for a single person in Portugal versus about €750 in Spain. (That is the absolute minimum.) Every single month, year after year.
So in terms of Cost of Living, the point goes to Portugal. Going into the final factor, Portugal leads 4 to 1. But what comes next is the thing that rewrites the entire result.
Factor 6 — Tax on US Retirement Income
For most of the 2010s and early 2020s, this comparison was settled before it started. Portugal’s Non-Habitual Resident regime — introduced in 2009 — gave qualifying retirees a flat 10 percent tax rate on foreign pension income for ten years. Spain’s progressive rates ran 19 to 47 percent. Every financial advisor said the same thing: Portugal wins on tax, and it’s not close.
That era is over. New applicants can no longer access the NHR. What replaced it — the IFICI program — focuses on working professionals and highly qualified employees, not retirees. Pure retirees fall entirely outside its scope.
Most expat retirees moving to Portugal in 2026 now face standard progressive IRS brackets running from 12.5 percent up to 48 percent, with a solidarity surcharge at the higher levels. The first €4,104 of pension income is tax-exempt — but the rest flows through the brackets like any other income.
Spain’s Beckham Law — the flat 24 percent regime — also doesn’t apply to retirees. All four qualifying categories require active work: employment, directorship, entrepreneurial activity, or professional services. So we’re comparing two progressive systems, straight up, with no special regime cushioning either side.
The scenario: a single US retiree, $50,000 per year in private pension income — gives €46,300 at the current exchange rate. In Portugal, the €4,104 pension exemption drops taxable income to around €42,200. Running through the 2026 IRS brackets — 13.25 percent at the bottom, climbing to 43.5 percent on the top slice — the estimated tax bill lands at around €11,705. Effective rate: about 25%. Standard health deductions could bring that down to 22 to 25 percent.
In Spain, a retiree over 65 gets a personal minimum allowance of €6,700 plus a pension-holder reduction of around €2,000, dropping taxable income to about €37,600. Running through the combined state and Andalusia regional brackets — 19 percent at the bottom, topping out at 37 percent — the estimated IRPF bill comes to around €9,613. Effective rate: about 21 percent.
Annual difference: somewhere between €2,000 to €2,500 in Spain’s favor. Over 20 years, that’s more than €40,000 in extra taxes paid in Portugal — before accounting for what those annual savings could earn if invested. Let that sink in.
But… Spain does impose a Wealth Tax on worldwide assets above €700,000 net worth in Andalusia — investment portfolios, IRAs, 401(k)s, foreign real estate, all of it. Portugal has no equivalent general wealth tax, only a real estate-specific levy on high-value Portuguese property above €600,000. If your global net worth sits well above that threshold, Spain’s income tax advantage can partially or fully reverse. This is a scenario to model individually before choosing Spain on tax grounds alone.
For our base scenario — $50,000 pension, assets below €700,000 — Spain wins clearly. Factor 6 winner: Spain — and this is the biggest change we’ve seen over the last two years.
The Final Scorecard
If we just look at the raw score, Portugal wins. But this is not the same Portugal that dominated these comparisons five years ago — it has lost its most powerful financial weapon, and its real estate market has surged to one of the most overheated in Western Europe.
Spain has closed the gap across virtually every dimension, and its two wins — tax and real estate trajectory — hit your bank account every single year for the rest of your life.
Spain makes a lot of sense right now if you want to stretch your retirement savings further, provided their wealth tax doesn’t hit you. But if you care more about almost everyone speaking English and having incredible healthcare right down the street, Portugal is still hard to beat. If you’re interested in obtaining Portuguese citizenship, that remains one of Portugal’s most powerful long-term advantages for expats.
However… the old line that “Portugal wins everything” is no longer true. This is a real competition now with Spain. But what are the best places, the best cities to live and retire in Spain in 2026? There are places there with great quality of life and a cost of living 65% lower than in the US. Discover which Spanish cities make the best retirement destinations in our dedicated guide.
Want detailed reports on Portugal, Spain, and other countries covered in this article? Join the Patreon community
Levi Borba is the founder of expatriateconsultancy.com, creator of the channel The Expat, and best-selling author. You can find him on X here. Some of the links above might be affiliate links, meaning the author earns a small commission if you make a purchase.
